The latest trend in El País/the internet/Twitter is to publish innumerable articles 'debunking' the 'myths' of the independence referendum campaign in Catalonia. And every time one of these is published, there's a temptation to try to debunk the debunking. Answer it with more facts.
The truth is that these articles are a distraction. It doesn't matter whether Catalonia has ever been an independent state. It probably was in 1641 but who cares? It's a red herring. This is a moral question and opponents of the referendum have made no effort to engage with the moral question because they have no arguments.
What's really important is that it is right and fair that Catalans can vote to decide their political future. None of the opposition arguments, with their revisionism and legalese, their focus on process and judicial decisions, their twisted interpretation of the meaning of democracy, engages with the moral imperative at the heart of this question.